Wednesday, March 10, 2010
Horrible Start by Wang Might be Sign | Print |  Send
Written by Jonathan Leshanski (Contact & Archive) on April 20, 2009
  

Some would call it unpredictable.  Some would call it erratic.  But almost everyone agrees that pitching is variable.  Once you get past a handful of pitchers, some elite, some far from that standard, it’s hard to predict how good a pitcher will be one season down the line.

Pitchers get derailed for so many reasons and even sometimes no reason at all.  You don’t have to look far for those kinds of pitchers -- Dontrelle Willis is an example, and Rick Ankiel, now an outfielder, is another.  One day they just stepped to the mound and couldn’t find the strike zone.  Both cases may be due to some form of mental trauma or even stress.   And while I can’t put my finger on when Willis lost his mojo, I watched Ankiel lose his under the pressure of his first playoff appearance versus the Braves in game 1 of the 2000 NLDS when in a single inning he walked four batters and threw five wild pitches.  It was presumed the problem was psychological, but Ankiel never managed to outgrow it.

wang_chien_ming
Chien-Ming Wang has a 34.50 ERA and more losses (3) than strikeouts (2).
Certainly the analogy hasn’t been lost on Yankees fans as they wonder just what has happened to Chien-Ming Wang, a pitcher who won 19 games in back to back seasons in 2006-2007.  The case however may not be a parallel, as Wang was coming off a foot surgery which sidelined him for the large part of the 2008 season.   That means the problem may be mechanical, as is clearly the case across town where Mets starter John Maine has been struggling.  That is a case that might be more of a parallel, as Maine, like Wang, is coming off surgery.
Admittedly Maine’s surgery was more likely to affect his throw; he had bone spurs shaved off of his shoulder joint.  As a result he’s been struggling to keep his command and stay consistent pitch after pitch.  But Maine at least hasn’t been disastrous so far this season.

Wang on the other hand has been.  With three starts under his belt so far Wang has yet to last more than 3.2 innings in a single game and has lasted a total of six innings in those three starts.  That goes with an ERA of 34.50, six walks, one wild pitch and one hit by pitch.   His spot in the rotation, as you might expect, is well deservedly in jeopardy. 

The problem is that the Yankees aren’t sure what to do about it.  Physically Wang appears to be fine, his delivery seems smooth and natural, his mechanics are not startlingly awry, but inning after inning he’s throwing batting practice to opponents.

Sending him down to the minors to work out his issues is what the team really should do and needs to do, but the team is already thin on pitching, not just at the top of the rotation but deep in the bullpen.  Wang may be partly to blame for the team’s second worst in the AL (and third worst overall) ERA, but he’s not the only one, as six other pitchers including Joba Chamberlain have ERAs over 5 -- and there aren’t many better options lurking in the minors at the moment.

That means the Yankees need Wang to get over this issue and quickly.  Having to demote him for a few starts isn’t something that scares this team, but the concern that his problem is more than mechanical is.  It isn’t often that a pitcher who loses “it,” no matter if you think “it” is control of the strike zone or that mental edge, seems to come back. 
That’s what frightens the Yankees and their fans, the thought that perhaps Wang is fine physically, but not within the confines of his own mind.  In terms of star power that wouldn’t rank up there with the loss of A-Rod or Jeter, but in terms of baseball, losing Wang could sabotage the whole season.

Pitching is unpredictable, but the one thing the Yankees are sure of is that without Wang they probably don’t have enough of it.

Check back Wednesday as Adam and Daniel debate how the Yankees should react to the Chien-Ming Wang situation.

Add your comment

Your name:
Your website:
Subject:
Comment:
  The word for verification. Lowercase letters only with no spaces.
Word verification:


Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Reddit! Del.icio.us! Mixx! Free and Open Source Software News Google! Live! Facebook! StumbleUpon! TwitThis Joomla Free PHP
 

Sponsored Links

Share AHP

At Home Plate wants you

Do you dream of becoming a sportswriter? We always have room for writers, editors, fact checkers, photographers, graphic designers, and web gurus to help us make the site even better. Come chase your dream with us. For more information click here.

At Home Plate Podcast

To listen to or download the latest At Home Plate Podcast, please click here.
To subscribe, click the icon below
Podcast Feed

Baseball DVDs

Donations

If you like At Home Plate, you could show your appreciation by donating a small amount to our team. Thank you very much!

Amount: